- 2013
- Best New Pizza Restaurant Voted by WPXI TV Pittsburgh
- 2015
- Best Pizza in Bloomfield Readers’ Choice Awards Pittsburgh Tribune Review
- Thrillist “Best Bar in Pittsburgh”
- Thrillist Names our Cheesy Bread” Best last night Eats”
- Gold for Best Pizza in the City Readers’ Choice Awards Pittsburgh Tribune Review
- 2nd place King of the Wing Honey SIrachi
- Bronze for New Business in North Hills Readers’ Choice Awards Pittsburgh Tribune Review
- Named Rogue Brewery’s Pittsburgh Embassy
- Named in the book Mid Atlantic Beer Lovers Best Brewery’s, brew pubs and beer bars
- 2016
- Best Pan Pizza in the World International Pizza Expo
- 2nd Place Pizza Maker Of the Year Las Vegas, Nevada
- Thrillist Best Pittsburgh bar with best late night or anytime eats
- Gold For Pizza best Pizza in the City Readers’ Choice Awards Pittsburgh Tribune Review
- Gold For Best Pizza In the North Hills Readers’ Choice Awards Pittsburgh Tribune Review
- Gold For Best Hoagies in the North Hills Readers’ Choice Awards Pittsburgh Tribune Review
- Silver for Wings and Chicken in the City Readers’ Choice Awards Pittsburgh Tribune Review
- Bronze 2016 Independent Business in the North Hills Readers’ Choice Awards Pittsburgh Tribune Review
- 2017
- Gold Medal World’s Largest Pizza Stretch at the World Pizza Games at Pizza Expo
- 1st place East Division Traditional Pizza at the World International Pizza Expo
- 1st place East Division Non-Traditional Pizza at the World International Pizza Expo
- Gold Best Pizza in Pittsburgh Readers’ Choice Awards Pittsburgh Tribune Review
- 2nd Place Fastest Dough Stretch Columbus Ohio Midwestern Pizza Trails
- 3rd Place Fastest Box Folding Midwestern Pizza Trails Columbus Ohio
- 3rd Place Largest Dough Stretch Midwestern Pizza Trails Columbus Ohio
- Silver For Takeout in the City Readers’ Choice Awards Pittsburgh Tribune Review
- Gold Best Wings in the City Readers’ Choice Awards Pittsburgh Tribune Review
- Gold Best Pizza in Bloomfield Readers’ Choice Awards Pittsburgh Tribune Review
- Gold Best Pizza in the North Hills Readers’ Choice Awards Pittsburgh Tribune Review
- 2018
